Christmas with Holly (2012) poster

2012 · drama · family · tv-movie

Christmas with Holly

Directed by Allan Arkush1h 30m2012

After being dumped at the altar on her wedding day, Maggie Conway moves to the island town of Friday Harbor in Washington State, where she meets Mark Nagle, the local coffee shop owner.

Our read: Christmas with Holly (2012) reads as a cosy, steady, grounded drama · family · tv-movie entry — gentle in intensity, intimate in scope, tender in temperature, redemptive in outlook.

Tonight with your partner? Play this film’s board Spin your lens Where to watch

Cast

Sean Faris Eloise Mumford Lucy Gallina Dana Watkins Daniel Eric Gold

Movie DNA

Cosy, steady, gentle drama / family, grounded in texture. Redemptive, intimate, tender.

ElsewhereIMDb7.14k

cosy
gentle
redemptive
tender
intimate

Game · before you press play

Watching Christmas with Holly tonight? Spin for your lens.

Everyone on the couch spins once and gets one craft to watch for. After the credits, compare what you caught.

Your lens for tonight

?

Everyone on the couch gets one craft to watch for. Spin the wheel to get yours. Sound on: the narrator reads your mission.

Where to watch

Not on streaming here right now.Check JustWatch Check Letterboxd

More info & search links

JustWatch Letterboxd IMDb TMDb YouTube

Where the cast leads

Forever Strong (2008) poster

Sean Faris thread

Yours, Mine & Ours (2005) poster

Yours, Mine & Ours

Sean Faris thread

Fifty Shades Freed (2018) poster

Fifty Shades Freed

Eloise Mumford thread

Fifty Shades Darker (2017) poster

Fifty Shades Darker

Eloise Mumford thread

actor path

Forever Strongsame tone Yours, Mine & Oursnear DNA The Lost Valentinenear DNA

actor path

Fifty Shades Freedadjacent Fifty Shades Darkeradjacent Just in Time for Christmasnear DNA

DNA · twelve axes

How Christmas with Holly feels to watch.

Each axis is scored by hand, not from votes or genre averages. The bar uses the film's own colours.

MoodHeavy ↔ Cosy

PacingSlow-burn ↔ Kinetic

IntensityGentle ↔ Extreme

WeirdnessConventional ↔ Surreal

HopeNihilistic ↔ Redemptive

StakesIntimate ↔ Epic

HumourNone ↔ Broad

RealityGrounded ↔ Fantastical

DensitySparse ↔ Twisty

WarmthCold ↔ Tender

AuteurTransparent ↔ Signature

Tonight, this looks like

What watching it is actually like.

“You want a gentle Hallmark-style Christmas story of healing and new love.”

ends warmyou’ll feel glowing aftera slow buildgrips by minute 15attention 2/5breezes by

Date nightWith friendsSoloWith parentsKids around

Skip it tonight — You hate predictable holiday romances or want edgier fare.

If Christmas with Holly is your film

The Holiday (2006)

Holiday romance and emotional healing in charming settings

(You want small town focus)

Love Actually (2003)

Ensemble Christmas stories of love and loss

(You want single heroine focus)

While You Were Sleeping (1995)

Warm holiday rom-com with found family and second chances

(You need the grief element)

Nearest by DNA

Eight films that feel like this one.

Closest in the twelve-axis space, not “people also liked”. All films like Christmas with Holly, with why →

Christmas Cottage (2008) poster

Christmas Cottage2008 · very close

Anne of Green Gables (2016) poster

Anne of Green Gables2016 · very close

Front of the Class (2008) poster

Front of the Class2008 · very close

Flicka: Country Pride (2012) poster

Flicka: Country Pride2012 · close

A Street Cat Named Bob (2016) poster

A Street Cat Named Bob2016 · close

Where Hope Grows (2014) poster

Where Hope Grows2014 · close

I'll Be Home for Christmas (2016) poster

I'll Be Home for Christmas2016 · close

Nostalgic Christmas (2019) poster

Nostalgic Christmas2019 · close

Your take

Rate it

React

Discussion

Discussion

cmd enter to post

Make it a movie night.

Pick a mood, get a film the whole couch will enjoy, and give everyone something to watch for.

Pick tonight's film →

Watching with your partner?Play this film’s board