OurMovieNights
Eye for an Eye (2025) poster

2025 · horror · supernatural · monster

Eye for an Eye

Directed by Colin Tilley1h 41m2025

Anna, grieving the sudden death of her parents, relocates from New York to a small Florida town to live with the grandmother she has never met. Isolated, vulnerable, and in need of friends, she finds brief solace in the company of two local teens. But when she becomes complicit to their unforgivable act of violence, she finds herself ensnared by Mr. Sandman – the twisted soul of a tormented child who haunts bullies’ dreams before feasting on their eyeballs when they finally wake - Anna must right her wrong before becoming a victim of this gruesome curse.

Our read: Eye for an Eye (2025) reads as a sombre, kinetic, surreal horror · supernatural · monster entry — extreme in intensity, mid-stakes in scope, measured in temperature, ambivalent in outlook.

Movie DNA

Sombre, kinetic, extreme horror / supernatural, surreal in texture. Ambivalent, mid-stakes, measured.

ElsewhereIMDb4.9813RT85%
  • sombre
  • brisk
  • extreme
  • surreal
Game · before you press play

Watching Eye for an Eye tonight? Spin for your lens.

Everyone on the couch spins once and gets one craft to watch for. After the credits, compare what you caught.

Your lens for tonight

?

Everyone on the couch gets one craft to watch for. Spin the wheel to get yours. Sound on: the narrator reads your mission.

Where to watch
Not on streaming here right now.Check JustWatch Check Letterboxd
More info & search links
Where the cast leads
DNA · twelve axes

How Eye for an Eye feels to watch.

Each axis is scored by hand, not from votes or genre averages. The bar uses the film's own colours.

MoodHeavy ↔ Cosy
PacingSlow-burn ↔ Kinetic
IntensityGentle ↔ Extreme
WeirdnessConventional ↔ Surreal
HopeNihilistic ↔ Redemptive
StakesIntimate ↔ Epic
HumourNone ↔ Broad
RealityGrounded ↔ Fantastical
DensitySparse ↔ Twisty
WarmthCold ↔ Tender
AuteurTransparent ↔ Signature
Tonight, this looks like

What watching it is actually like.

“You want atmospheric folk horror with a vengeful dream entity exacting justice.”

ends unsettlingit leaves you shakengrabs you earlygrips from the openattention 4/5breezes by
Date nightWith friendsSoloWith parentsKids around
Heads-upgoregraphic violencebody horrorchild peril

Skip it tonight — You hate gore or eye violence and stories of complicity.

Nearest by DNA

Eight films that feel like this one.

Closest in the twelve-axis space, not “people also liked”. All films like Eye for an Eye, with why →

Your take
Rate it
star-clip-1-0star-clip-2-0star-clip-3-0star-clip-4-0star-clip-5-0
React
Discussion

Discussion

cmd enter to post

Make it a movie night.

Pick a mood, get a film the whole couch will enjoy, and give everyone something to watch for.

Pick tonight's film →
Watching with your partner?Play this film’s board